Shadow of the Erdtree: Ranking all Remembrance bosses from masterpiece to pure pain

Having beaten the DLC three times across pure Strength, Dex/Bleed, and Faith/Arcane builds, here is my definitive combat tier list:

1. Messmer the Impaler (S Tier): The best rhythm and visual choreography in modern FromSoft history. Puts your dodge discipline to the test without visual clutter.

2. Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame (A+ Tier): Spooky mansion buildup, haunting soundtrack, and beautifully deliberate sword sweeps.

3. Rellana, Twin Moon Knight (A Tier): Relentless aggression done right. Pontiff Sulyvahn spiritual successor.

4. Promised Consort (B- Tier): Spectacular Phase 1, but Phase 2 particle brightness is still blinding on HDR displays.

What does your top 3 look like?